Download full text
(external source)
Citation Suggestion
Please use the following Persistent Identifier (PID) to cite this document:
https://doi.org/10.58036/stss.v13i1.931
Exports for your reference manager
Legitimate Corruption: Ethics of Bureaucracy and Kinship in Central Asia
[journal article]
Abstract The World Bank and Transparency International rank the Central Asian republics as highly corrupt. This is an opinion that is also shared by international media and by NGO personnel and academics working on the ground in these countries. Yet, the kind of practices that are labelled as "corrupt" by th... view more
The World Bank and Transparency International rank the Central Asian republics as highly corrupt. This is an opinion that is also shared by international media and by NGO personnel and academics working on the ground in these countries. Yet, the kind of practices that are labelled as "corrupt" by these observers seem much too diverse to meaningfully be covered by the same term, such as illicit selling and buying of government contracts at the highest level; tax evasion in the millions; the faster processing of a passport for a relative; and a taxi driver bribing the traffic police. This presents both an analytical and an ethical problem. This article argues that condemning discourses on corruption are often used by the powerful both nationally and internationally to dominate colonised and marginalised groups. Such groups, excluded from or exploited within formal structures, rely on networks and communities for their livelihoods. The upkeep of these social relations comes into conflict with the imperatives of state law and bureaucracy. Anti-corruption thus becomes a weapon of the strong against the weak and aligns with a long history of colonial tradition of domination and vilification of those "yet-to-be-civilised." Its focus on regions of the Global South such as Central Asia marks a continuation of colonial legacy but also the region's continued marginality in the capitalist world system. This article posits that in order solve these analytical and ethical problems, we must be careful not to conflate a legal state-notion of corruption with a moral one thus accepting as default the perspective of the dominant groups running states and organisations.... view less
Keywords
corruption; Kyrgyzstan; bureaucracy; kinship; colonialism; Central Asia
Classification
Organizational Sociology
Ethnology, Cultural Anthropology, Ethnosociology
Free Keywords
Xinjiang; coloniality
Document language
English
Publication Year
2021
Page/Pages
p. 3-20
Journal
Studies of Transition States and Societies, 13 (2021) 1
ISSN
1736-8758
Status
Published Version; peer reviewed