Download full text
(885.0Kb)
Citation Suggestion
Please use the following Persistent Identifier (PID) to cite this document:
https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:0168-ssoar-384875
Exports for your reference manager
The case for spatially-sensitive data: how data structures affect spatial measurement and substantive theory
Raumsensible Daten: wie Datenstrukturen räumlich-geographisches Messen substantielle Theorie beeinflussen
[journal article]
Abstract Innovations in GIS and spatial statistics offer exciting opportunities to examine novel questions and to revisit established theory. Realizing this promise requires investment in spatially-sensitive data. Though convenient, widely-used administrative datasets are often spatially insensitive. They li... view more
Innovations in GIS and spatial statistics offer exciting opportunities to examine novel questions and to revisit established theory. Realizing this promise requires investment in spatially-sensitive data. Though convenient, widely-used administrative datasets are often spatially insensitive. They limit our ability to conceptualize and measure spatial relationships, leading to problems with ecological validity and the MAUP – with profound implications for substantive theory. I dramatize the stakes using the case of supermarket red-lining in 1970 Chicago. I compare the analytical value of a popular, spatially insensitive administrative dataset with that of a custom-built, spatially sensitive alternative. I show how the former constrains analysis to a single count measure and aspatial regression, while the latter’s point data support multiple measures and spatially-sensitive regression procedures; leading to starkly divergent results. In establishing the powerful impact that spatial measures can exert on our theoretical conclusions, I highlight the perils of relying on convenient, but insensitive datasets. Concomitantly, I demonstrate why investing in spatially sensitive data is essential for advancing sound knowledge of a broad array of historical and contemporary spatial phenomena.... view less
Keywords
zone; regional factors; neighborhood; analysis; research approach; urban sociology; statistics; urban research; retail trade; data capture
Classification
Economic and Social Geography
Methods and Techniques of Data Collection and Data Analysis, Statistical Methods, Computer Methods
Method
development of methods; basic research
Free Keywords
spatial regression; spatially-sensitive data; spatial measurement; ecological validity; Modifiable Areal Unit Problem (MAUP); retail red-lining; supermarket access; neighborhood effects
Document language
English
Publication Year
2014
Page/Pages
p. 315-346
Journal
Historical Social Research, 39 (2014) 2
Issue topic
Spatial analysis
DOI
https://doi.org/10.12759/hsr.39.2014.2.315-346
ISSN
0172-6404
Status
Published Version; peer reviewed