Download full text
(598.2Kb)
Citation Suggestion
Please use the following Persistent Identifier (PID) to cite this document:
https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:0168-ssoar-322989
Exports for your reference manager
On the dialectics of power and revolution: a few reflections on the work of John Holloway "Change the World Without Taking Power"
[monograph]
Abstract This study consists in a critical approach to Holloway’s ‘Open Marxism’, as presented in his Change the world without taking power.
In defense of the so-called revolutionary Marxist tradition, represented by radical Marxist thinkers as Lenin, Trotsky, Luxemburg, Gramsci and Lukács, the author stro... view more
This study consists in a critical approach to Holloway’s ‘Open Marxism’, as presented in his Change the world without taking power.
In defense of the so-called revolutionary Marxist tradition, represented by radical Marxist thinkers as Lenin, Trotsky, Luxemburg, Gramsci and Lukács, the author strongly opposes Holloway’s argument that scientific Marxism in toto succumbed actually to the bourgeois ideology of science, state, power etc. Consequently, this analysis focuses on how Holloway himself mistreats crucial concepts such as ‘science’, ‘state’, ‘party’ and ‘power’.
Victim and fanatic of a theology of Negation, Holloway follows an abstract ‘either-or’ mode of thinking and arguing, and fails to treat dialectically critical relations as those among science and ideology, state and revolution, movement and party.
According to this study, Holloway’s anti-capitalistic rhetoric and post-modernist methodology are nothing more than expressions of an old-fashioned anarchist ideology, against which classical Marxism, adapted to contemporary needs and conditions, can function as a radical critique.
As the author suggests, searching for the meaning of the revolution nowadays, Holloway confuses the Marxist concept of science with the positivistic one and fatally mistakes a political caricature of Marxism, i.e. a Blanquist or/ and a Stalinist misinterpretation of the Marxist theory of revolution, for revolutionary Marxism itself.... view less
Keywords
capitalism; positivism; political power; epistemology; Marxism; communism; revolution; dialectics; theory of society
Classification
Philosophy, Ethics, Religion
Basic Research, General Concepts and History of Political Science
Method
epistemological
Free Keywords
Holloway, J.
Document language
English
Publication Year
2012
Page/Pages
77 p.
Status
Published Version; not reviewed
Licence
Creative Commons - Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works